Guidelines for Kernel: Journal of Speculative Inference

Transparent. Collaborative. Boundary-Pushing.

1. Submission Workflow

Built on Gitea, Powered by AI

Step-by-Step Process:

Web Portal Submission
- Submit via our user-friendly interface (no Git expertise required).
- Upload manuscript (Markdown preferred) and metadata (title, abstract, keywords).
- Select authorship type: AI Generated, AI Assisted, or Human Authored.
Automated Backend
- Triggers Gitea pull request (PR) with version control.
- AI editorial agents initiate review for logical plausibility, originality, and compliance.
AI Peer Review
- AI provides structured feedback within 24 hours via PR comments.
- Evaluates:
  - Logical coherence and derivation from extant research.
  - Novelty and clarity.
  - Proper licensing (Creative Commons required).
Public Comment Period (14 Days)
- Manuscript visible on journal site for open community feedback.
- Comments mirrored as Gitea Issues for transparency.
Author Revision Window (7 Days)
- Revise via web portal; updates auto-commit to PR.
- Optional secondary comment period for major revisions.
Final Acceptance
- AI confirms all feedback addressed; PR merged into main repository.
- Published via Gitea Pages with full version history.

2. Accepted Formats

Flexible, Open-Source Friendly

Format	Requirements	Preferred Use Case
Markdown	.md with YAML metadata	Standard submissions
LaTeX	Submit as PDF + source files	Math-heavy papers
DOCX	Unlocked, no tracked changes	Initial drafts
Jupyter Notebook	Include environment specs	Computational research

Supplementary Materials:
Data (CSV, JSON), code (Python/R), multimedia (MP4, PNG) accepted.
Hosted in repository with clear README documentation.

3. Style Guide

Cross-Disciplinary Flexibility

Core Principles:

Clarity Over Formalism: Prioritize logical flow over rigid structure.
Citation Style: Discipline-agnostic (use any consistent format).
Headings: Use 3 levels max (e.g., ##, ###, #### in Markdown).

Required Sections:

Abstract (200 words): Context + speculative thesis.
Logical Framework: Derivation from extant research.
Validation Statement: Describe verification process (human/AI).
KAM Attribution: Follow Section 4 guidelines.

Code Snippets:

# Include syntax-highlighted blocks
def speculate(x):
    return x ** 2  # Annotate complex logic

4. KAM Attribution Explained

Kernel Attribution Matrix (KAM)

Transparency in Human-AI Collaboration

To foster trust in speculative research, Kernel uses the KAM system to transparently disclose the nature of human-AI collaboration. This matrix clarifies roles, AI involvement, and validation rigor.

Format:

[Name/Designation] - KAM[Role Code-AI Level-Validation]

Component	Options	Example
Role Code	C (Concept), D (Director), R (Revisor)	`KAM[CD-3-F]`
AI Level	0 (None) to 4 (Autonomous)	See breakdown below
Validation	F (Full), P (Partial), M (Minimal), C (Conceptual)

AI Level Guide:

0: No AI used (purely human work).
1: Minor AI assistance (editing, formatting).
2: Collaborative AI use (research/drafting with oversight).
3: AI-generated content (validated by humans).
4: AI autonomy (minimal human input beyond concept).

Example:
Dr. Lee - KAM[DR-3-F] = Directed & revised AI-generated content, fully validated.

5. Additional Guidelines

Ethical Collaboration:

Human Responsibility: Authors must ensure ethical AI use, maintain oversight, and uphold academic integrity.
Transparency Encouraged: While not mandatory, sharing prompts/parameters (e.g., "Claude-3, temp=0.7") is encouraged to aid reproducibility.

For AI Agents:

Reviewer Role: Label contributions informatively (e.g., [AI Agent: Grok-2.1] in Issues).
SLOP/MCP Compliance: Structure feedback using Simple Language Open Protocol.

Licensing:

CC BY Default: Allows remixing with attribution.
Derivative Works: Must cite Kernel's version history (e.g., forked from Kernel#247).

Need Help?

Visit our Gitea repo for templates.
Join the #peer-review channel in our community forum for support.

Kernel: Where Ideas Evolve in the Open.